Industrial leaders vs robber barons ever since the colonization period in the 1600s, many settlers had come to north america as a land of opportunity as civilizations became developed in america, many will see that this hope will be realized. 1 describe klein's distinction between industrial pirates and industrial statesmen provide examples of each 2 explain what klein means by an emotional: versus a more analytical and objective approach to interpretations of the robber baron. - the industrial leaders of the 19th century should be admired for their work the industrial leaders, robber barons, of the 19th century are men who are very respected and admired andrew carnegie was a boy from scotland who came over to this country with nothing. Best answer: robber baron (industrialist) robber baron is a pejorative term used for a powerful 19th century american businessman by the 1890s the term was used to attack any businessman who used questionable practices to become wealthy.
The industrial leaders of the 19th century should be admired for their work the industrial leaders, robber barons, of the 19th century are men who are very respected and admired andrew carnegie was a boy from scotland who came over to this country with nothing. In general the industrial leaders of the 19th century were robber barons before industrial solons however now that america is cognizant of the good that concern colossuss can make possibly future coevalss will take after the solons. Robber barons or industrial statesmen: here is some information that will help you answer the question i will describe two ways of accumulating wealth. The robber barons: the article mentions morgan, rockefeller and carnegie and discusses oil, steel, electricity and government regulations history of us steel: the article discusses the history of the united states steel corporation and both andrew carnegie and jp morgan.
The men who took advantage of these opportunities were more robber barons than they were industrial statesmen more often than not, greed overcame their decisions as capitalists during the gilded age, the leaders of industry worked towards self-interest, and thus were called robber barons. In reality the debate over robber barons and captains of industry mirrors views of industrialism itself just as their were both positives and negatives to industrialism there were positives and negatives to the leaders of industrialism. I'm doing a dbq for ap us history and the prompt is : to what extent was it justified to characterize the industrial leaders of the late 19th century as either “robber barons” or “industrial statesmen. Ap us history dbq essay: robber barons or industrial statesmen due date: march 9th some historians have characterized the entrepreneurs of the late 19 th century as “robber barons “ -- ruthless predators others have depicted them as “captains of industry,” enlightened businessmen. Essays: robber baron or industrial statesmen to what extent is it justified to characterize the industrial leaders of the 1865- 1900 era as either robber baron in the era following the civil war, industrialization had many leaders.
Some historians consider industrial statesmen to what we now robber baron captain d thoughts and go andrew carnegie robber barons do we consider the treatment of his essay writing service 24/7 behavior out why, as a working man, when robber barons essay. The leaders of these industries were looked upon as robber barons by some and industrial statesmen by others the downside was that the way the industrial leaders treated their employees was harsh and unfair. The majority of the industrial leaders of the 1865-1900 era were robber barons they utilized child and immigrant labor and paid them very little and gave them no benefits.
In reality the debate over robber barons and captains of industry mirrors the views of industrialism itself just as there were both positives and negatives to industrialism, there were positives and negatives to the leaders of industrialism. Robber baron or captain of industry dbq - we will be reviewing the documents for our dbq in class monday before you all get started on it your task is to answer whether or not you think the richest people of industries were 'robber barons' or 'industrial statesmen. Nevins, in his 1940 two-volume work john d rockefeller: the heroic age of american enterprise, challenged the previous perspective by advocating the new industrial statesman view and applying it to one of the most well-known of the robber barons. Essays related to robber barons vs captains of industry 1 in regard to the industrial period, a robber baron was someone who was thought of as immoral and deceitful, who used others to make money, while a captain of industry was someone who was a great leader that used his success for the benefit of the mankind while a captain.
Despite the disgraceful actions of the robber barons, industrial leaders were sometimes the shining examples of industrial statesmen the greatest example was the economic revolution that occurred america was, and is, made up of immigrants because it is widely know as the “land of opportunity. Although they were industrial statesmen, it is justifiable to say that the industrial leaders of the 1865-1900 era were also robber barons there is no doubt that even the most corrupt industrial leaders were brilliant. Robber baron this term is used to criticize the same businessmen who claimed to be statesmen critics pointed out that business leaders became incredibly rich by taking advantage of workers and consumers.